'Follow the Settlements' Doctrine: Implications on a Reinsured's Allocation and Aggregation of Losses

The applicability of the bedrock reinsurance principle of "follow the settlements" is at the core of an increasing number of recent reinsurance disputes concerning whether a reinsurer must follow the manner its reinsureds allocate and aggregate underlying losses. Over the last 5 years, a number of courts have addressed whether the doctrine of "follow the settlements" precludes a reinsurer from second-guessing its reinsured's determination of how it allocated and/or aggregated losses in resolving disputes with the underlying insured. As discussed more fully below, reinsureds typically argue that under the "follow the settlements" doctrine, a reinsurer must defer to the allocation and aggregation decisions of its reinsured, provided those decisions are made in good faith. Reinsurers on the other hand, typically argue that "follow the settlements" is not unlimited, but that the reinsured's decisions must be consistent with the language of the reinsurance agreement.

37 minute read November 30, 2004 at 09:16 AM

By

Stephen T. Murray And Steven J. Torres