Business Manager Denied New Trial In Malmsteen Case

An expert witness for Malmsteen testified that music-industry business managers are “customarily responsible for ' maintain[ing] awareness of all professional and personal income earned by [a] client and [ensuring] the collection of this income” and “generally ' do everything the client would do for himself if the client had the time and was not working.” After a trial, the jury ruled for the plaintiff on breach of contract and breach of fiduciary obligation claims. (The judge ruled for the defendants as a matter of law on Malmsteen's fraud claim.) Of the breach claim, the district judge subsequently noted: “[t]here was sufficient evidence from which a reasonable jury could have found that Mitnick, acting as a business manager, agreed to monitor plaintiffs' income and verify that payments to plaintiff were properly accounted for.” Mitnick argued there could be no breach because the jury awarded no damages on that claim, but the court explained: “The jury's failure to award damages on plaintiff's breach of contract claim was likely its attempt to comply with the [c]ourt's instruction that they could not award 'actual damages more than once for the same loss' if they found for plaintiff on both the breach of contract and breach of fiduciary duty claims.” The jury awarded Malmsteen $450,000 on the fiduciary-breach claim.