Insurers' Rights to Recoup Defense Costs
Commercial General Liability ("CGL") policies typically provide two distinct benefits to policyholders: defense against potentially covered claims, and indemnity against covered claims. Because the duty to defend is broader than the duty to indemnify, it is as important, if not more important, than the duty to indemnify. <i>See, e.g., Buss v. Los Angeles Superior Court</i>, 65 Cal.Rptr.2d 366, 373, 939 P.2d 766, 773 (1997). Insurers often accept their defense obligations, however, subject to reservation of their rights to assert non-coverage. Now, with increasing frequency, insurers also are demanding reimbursement if it turns out that the liability claim was not covered.
The Leasing Hotline
Highlights of the latest commercial leasing cases from around the country.
In the Spotlight: Exploring the 'Gray' Between Ground and Space Leases
There are frequently varying shades of gray between a true ground lease and a space lease, particularly in retail real estate. The true ground lease is exactly that: a lease of ground — dirt — generally for a long term where the landlord has few, if any, obligations and, in fact, few rights other than to collect a rent stream which can only be interrupted in extremely limited circumstances. A space lease, of course, provides a landlord with varying responsibilities from construction to maintenance, repair, enforcement of other tenant obligations, etc., as well as creating various landlord rights such as use restrictions, radius restrictions, continuous operation provisions, etc. Landlords often get into trouble when they blend concepts from both ground and space leases without carefully considering whether the blend actually works throughout the lease term.
Who Is in the Chain of Liability for OFAC Noncompliance?
By now many of us have either heard or read several articles written about compliance with the Executive Order 13224, titled "Blocking Property and Prohibiting Transactions with Persons Who Commit, Threaten to Commit, or Support Terrorism" (the "Executive Order"). Although the probability of leasing or selling to any "Persons Who Commit, Threaten to Commit, or Support Terrorism," is extremely low, the consensus among the real estate bar seems to be that it is better to comply with the Executive Order and protect yourself and your client rather than risk the stiff penalties and stigma that would follow by inadvertently violating it. It is apparent that the creation of a Landlord-Tenant relationship or a conveyance of a property interest would give rise to an obligation to comply with the Executive Order, thereby triggering all of the potential liability associated with violating it.
Features
Terrorism Insurance: A Two-Edged Sword
In the landlord-tenant arena, the issue of whether terrorism insurance must be purchased has two frequently encountered aspects. In one factual pattern, a tenant of a single-user property is required by its lease to purchase certain insurance coverage to protect both its own interest and the landlord's. Does this lease provision include terrorism insurance, as well as other types of coverage generally required on the leased premises? In another factual pattern, tenants of a multi-tenant facility must reimburse the landlord for their share of the landlord's taxes, common area expenses and insurance premiums. Do those insurance premiums properly include the landlord's cost of obtaining terrorism insurance?
Features
Eminent Domain Law
Recent cases of importance to your practice.
Features
Selling the State's Zoning Exemption?
The Court of Appeals recently confronted a significant zoning issue: When, and on what terms, can the state or a state agency transfer to a private entity its exemption from local zoning restrictions? In <i>Matter of Crown Communication New York, Inc. v. Department of Transportation</i> (NYLJ 2/14/05, p. 19, col. 4), a divided court held that telecommunications towers erected on state land were immune from local zoning regulations even when the much of the space on the towers had been leased to private companies. The court's decision, however, raises as many questions as it resolves.
Features
Real Property Law
Rulings of interest to you and your practice.
Need Help?
- Prefer an IP authenticated environment? Request a transition or call 800-756-8993.
- Need other assistance? email Customer Service or call 1-877-256-2472.
MOST POPULAR STORIES
- Second Circuit Rejects Arbitration of Debtor's Asserted Discharge ViolationA bankruptcy court properly denied a bank's motion to compel arbitration of a debtor's asserted violation of the court's discharge injunction, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit held.Read More ›
- Reining in the Inequitable Conduct DefenseResponding to views from the U.S. Patent and Trademark Office and elsewhere about the unintended consequences of the current inequitable conduct doctrine, a divided <i>en banc</i> Federal Circuit decision issued on May 25, 2011 adjusted the standard of the materiality element to make this defense harder to establish.Read More ›
- 'Customary Operations' or A Vacant Building?Many times, courts are faced with the question of whether a loss location is 'vacant' under a commercial property policy when trying to determine if the building owner or lessee is conducting customary operations. This article explores various decisions across the United States as to what is considered 'customary operations,' thereby rendering the property 'vacant.'Read More ›
- Removing Restrictive Covenants In New YorkIn Rockwell v. Despart, the New York Supreme Court, Third Department, recently revisited a recurring question: When may a landowner seek judicial removal of a covenant restricting use of her land?Read More ›
- Judge Rules Shaquille O'Neal Will Face Securities Lawsuit for Promotion, Sale of NFTsA federal district court in Miami, FL, has ruled that former National Basketball Association star Shaquille O'Neal will have to face a lawsuit over his promotion of unregistered securities in the form of cryptocurrency tokens and that he was a "seller" of these unregistered securities.Read More ›