Law.com Subscribers SAVE 30%
Call 855-808-4530 or email [email protected] to receive your discount on a new subscription.
Co-ops and Condominiums
In Tax Foreclosure Proceeding, Condominium Board Entitled to Recover Only Those Common Charges Covered By Its Lien
NYCTL 2019-A Trust v. Opulski2024 WL 4743648
AppDiv, First Dept.
(memorandum opinion)
In a tax foreclosure proceeding, condominium unit owner appealed from Supreme Court’s grant of the motion of the condominium board for distribution of $225,775.91 in surplus proceeds from the foreclosure sale and from Supreme Court’s grant of unit owner’s former spouse’s motion for distribution of $60,831.51 in surplus proceeds to her. The Appellate Division modified to reduce the award to the Board and to deny the award to the spouse entirely.
Beginning some time in 2012, unit owner became delinquent in paying condominium common charges. The condominium board filed liens against the unit in 2014, 2015, 2017 and 2019 covering unpaid common charges dating back to January 2013, and brought a foreclosure proceeding in 2018 which it discontinued once the tax foreclosure proceeding was commenced. Meanwhile, unit owner’s spouse, who had been a partial owner of the unit, obtained a divorce, and the divorce judgment recited that unit owner would be the sole owner of the unit, while unit owner agreed to pay the spouse $85,000. When unit owner did not pay the full amount, the spouse obtained a money judgment for the balance, but the judgment was not entered until after the foreclosure sale. After the referee paid all taxes and other costs associated with the foreclosure sale, the referee delivered $366,759.64 in surplus proceeds to the court, and Supreme Court made distributions to the condominium board and the ex-spouse. Unit owner appealed.
In modifying, the Appellate Division first rejected unit owner’s claim that the condominium’s liens were time-barred. The court noted that the condominium’s claims were based on its 2019 lien, and the claim was made within six years of the lien’s expiration. The court held that the six-year time period refers not to the date the common charges accrued, but to the duration of the condominium’s lien. The court then rejected unit owner’s claim that the condominium board did not mitigate its damages, pointing to the condominium’s 2018 commencement of a foreclosure action. (The court did not determine whether the condominium had any duty to mitigate). But the court did hold that the condominium could not collect any of the common charges dating before January 2013, because that is the first period covered by the liens the condominium had filed. The court emphasized that in the foreclosure proceeding, the board was entitled only to amounts covered by the liens, not other debts owed by the unit owner.
The court then held that the former spouse was not entitled to share in the surplus proceeds because she had disclaimed her interest in the property during the divorce proceeding, and because her judgment against the unit owner was not entered until after the foreclosure sale. As a result, she was only a general creditor.
Comment
The Article 8 Opt In
The Article 8 opt-in election adds an additional layer of complexity to the already labyrinthine rules governing perfection of security interests under the UCC. A lender that is unaware of the nuances created by the opt in (may find its security interest vulnerable to being primed by another party that has taken steps to perfect in a superior manner under the circumstances.
Major Differences In UK, U.S. Copyright Laws
This article highlights how copyright law in the United Kingdom differs from U.S. copyright law, and points out differences that may be crucial to entertainment and media businesses familiar with U.S law that are interested in operating in the United Kingdom or under UK law. The article also briefly addresses contrasts in UK and U.S. trademark law.
Legal Possession: What Does It Mean?
Possession of real property is a matter of physical fact. Having the right or legal entitlement to possession is not "possession," possession is "the fact of having or holding property in one's power." That power means having physical dominion and control over the property.
Warehouse Liability: Know Before You Stow!
As consumers continue to shift purchasing and consumption habits in the aftermath of the pandemic, manufacturers are increasingly reliant on third-party logistics and warehousing to ensure their products timely reach the market.
Strategy vs. Tactics: Two Sides of a Difficult Coin
With each successive large-scale cyber attack, it is slowly becoming clear that ransomware attacks are targeting the critical infrastructure of the most powerful country on the planet. Understanding the strategy, and tactics of our opponents, as well as the strategy and the tactics we implement as a response are vital to victory.