Standing is the issue that determines whether a plaintiff is the right party to bring a case. Although it is a fundamental requirement for all cases, it poses unique challenges in the patent context, particularly for life sciences companies. This two-part article provides guiding principles and potential pitfalls for plaintiffs and defendants alike. In this first article, we lay out the Federal Circuit’s framework for analyzing standing in patent cases and explain what rights a patent owner must have in order to sue for patent infringement.
- March 01, 2026Matthew Chivvis and Sumaiya Sharmeen and Evelyn Li-Jin Chang and Maya Darrow
OSS delivers flexibility, scalability, and speed that few proprietary stacks can match. But the benefits outweigh the risks only if the risks are actively managed. The core lesson is structural. OSS copyright compliance is indispensable but incomplete. Patent exposure can attach even where distribution is lawful and good faith is undisputed, and contributor-based patent grants, even when well drafted, do not eliminate third-party assertion risk.
March 01, 2026Brandon TheissFederal Circuit: Issue Preclusion Precludes the Board from Reaching the Opposite Conclusion on PatentabilityFederal Circuit: Result-Oriented Claims that Fail to Disclose How the Alleged Goal is Achieve are Unpatentable
March 01, 2026Jeffrey Ginsberg and Kaiying WangFederal Circuit: “Complete Identity of Inventive Entity” Required to Remove Prior Art as Not By “Another” Under Pre-AIA LawFederal Circuit: No Trade Secret Misappropriation By Goodyear nor Correction of Inventorship Warranted Because of Coda’s Failure to Show Specificity, Secrecy, or Evidence of Use
January 01, 2026Jeffrey Ginsberg and Shelli GimelsteinGenerative AI is not an extinction-level event for patent prosecutors. It’s a force multiplier — an amplifier of legal analysis, not a replacement for it. If anything, it will allow practitioners to spend more time doing what clients value the most.
December 01, 2025Bryan McWhorterAs electronic discovery continues to evolve, pharmaceutical and technology companies — particularly those navigating the complexities of patent litigation — face a rapidly changing technological landscape that is increasingly influenced by AI tools.
December 01, 2025James R. Tyminski and Taskeen AmanFederal Circuit Holds That Patentee’s Disavowal of Claim Construction Warrants Reversal of Summary JudgmentFederal Circuit Concludes That Two Organizations Lack Associational Standing to Challenge USPTO’s Denial of Petition for Rulemaking
October 31, 2025Jeffrey Ginsberg and Basil WilliamsThe Rise of ‘Settled Expectations’ In USPTO Review and the Fallout for Patent Owners and Challengers
The landscape for discretionary denials at PTAB is evolving quickly; both patent challengers and owners must adapt their strategies to ensure they are not left behind by the USPTO’s new approach.
September 30, 2025Elizabeth Shuster and Anthony TomuskoMost days, preparing and prosecuting patent applications follows a familiar rhythm. Talk with the inventors. Draft the application. Wait for the Patent Office. Argue a few times. Secure the patent. Repeat. But every so often, a case reminds us that our work can mean much more — especially when something has gone wrong, and someone needs an advocate to make it right.
August 31, 2025Ryan WardIn Ex parte Michalek, the PTAB evaluated an invention involving medical health technology and artificial intelligence. While this case involved medical health technology, the implicated issues inform patent strategies for AI enabled inventions across all industries.
June 30, 2025Jim Soong










