Law.com Subscribers SAVE 30%

Call 855-808-4530 or email [email protected] to receive your discount on a new subscription.

IP News

By Howard J. Shire and Matthew Berkowitz

Federal Circuit to Hear EchoStar Appeal En Banc

On May 14, 2010 the Federal Circuit granted Defendants-Appellants EchoStar Corporation, et al.'s petition for rehearing en banc, vacated its March 4, 2010 opinion affirming a district court's decision finding EchoStar in contempt of the court's permanent injunction order, 597 F.3d 1247 (Fed. Cir. 2010), and requested that the parties file new briefs addressing the following issues:

  1. Following a finding of infringement by an accused device at trial, under what circumstances is it proper for a district court to determine infringement by a newly accused device through contempt proceedings rather than through new infringement proceedings? What burden of proof is required to establish that a contempt proceeding is proper?
  2. How does “fair ground of doubt as to the wrongfulness of the defendant's conduct” compare with the “more than colorable differences” or “substantial open issues of infringement” tests in evaluating the newly accused devices against the adjudged infringing device?
  3. Where a contempt proceeding is proper, (1) what burden of proof is on the patentee to show that the newly accused device infringes and (2) what weight should be given to the infringer's efforts to design around the patent and its reasonable and good faith belief of noninfringement by the new device, for a finding of contempt?
  4. Is it proper for a district court to hold an enjoined party in contempt where there is a substantial question as to whether the injunction is ambiguous in scope?

The case originated in 2004 when Tivo sued EchoStar in the U.S. District Court for the Easter District of Texas, alleging that EchoStar's DVR receivers infringed U.S. Patent No. 6,233,389. Following a jury finding of infringement, the district court entered judgment on the verdict and issued a permanent injunction against EchoStar ordering it to: 1) stop making, using, offering to sell, and selling the receivers that had been found to infringe by the jury, and 2) disable the DVR functionality in existing receivers that had not already been placed with subscribers. On appeal, the Federal Circuit affirmed the liability findings with respect to some of the claims and noted that the permanent injunction would take effect following the court's decision. Tivo then moved the district court to find EchoStar in contempt of the court's permanent injunction based on its sale of redesigned DVR receivers. After a series of hearings, the district court held EchoStar in contempt and imposed sanctions of nearly $90 million, rejecting EchoStar's argument that the redesigned receivers were more than colorably different from the adjudged infringing devices.

This premium content is locked for Entertainment Law & Finance subscribers only

  • Stay current on the latest information, rulings, regulations, and trends
  • Includes practical, must-have information on copyrights, royalties, AI, and more
  • Tap into expert guidance from top entertainment lawyers and experts

For enterprise-wide or corporate acess, please contact Customer Service at [email protected] or 877-256-2473

Read These Next
Bankruptcy Sales: Finding a Diamond In the Rough Image

There is no efficient market for the sale of bankruptcy assets. Inefficient markets yield a transactional drag, potentially dampening the ability of debtors and trustees to maximize value for creditors. This article identifies ways in which investors may more easily discover bankruptcy asset sales.

Judge Rules Shaquille O'Neal Will Face Securities Lawsuit for Promotion, Sale of NFTs Image

A federal district court in Miami, FL, has ruled that former National Basketball Association star Shaquille O'Neal will have to face a lawsuit over his promotion of unregistered securities in the form of cryptocurrency tokens and that he was a "seller" of these unregistered securities.

Why So Many Great Lawyers Stink at Business Development and What Law Firms Are Doing About It Image

Why is it that those who are best skilled at advocating for others are ill-equipped at advocating for their own skills and what to do about it?

Blockchain Domains: New Developments for Brand Owners Image

Blockchain domain names offer decentralized alternatives to traditional DNS-based domain names, promising enhanced security, privacy and censorship resistance. However, these benefits come with significant challenges, particularly for brand owners seeking to protect their trademarks in these new digital spaces.

Coverage Issues Stemming from Dry Cleaner Contamination Suits Image

In recent years, there has been a growing number of dry cleaners claiming to be "organic," "green," or "eco-friendly." While that may be true with respect to some, many dry cleaners continue to use a cleaning method involving the use of a solvent called perchloroethylene, commonly known as perc. And, there seems to be an increasing number of lawsuits stemming from environmental problems associated with historic dry cleaning operations utilizing this chemical.